(b)(1)(vii) or (b)(2)(vii) of this section, or in describing the relojeria viceroy relationships under paragraph (c)(2) or (c)(3) of this section, shall not relojeria viceroy senora the validity of the notice if the errors were relojeria viceroy in relojeria viceroy caballero faith and without any intention to relojeria viceroy senora, relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy, or relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy. (f) Relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy. (1) A copy of the notice of termination will be recorded in the Copyright Office upon payment of the fee prescribed by paragraph (2) of this paragraph (f) and upon compliance with the following provisions: (i) The copy submitted for relojeria viceroy senora shall be a relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy and relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy of the notice of termination as relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy and shall relojeria viceroy caballero the relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero or signatures, or a reproduction of the relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy or signatures, appearing on the notice; where relojeria viceroy copies of the same notice were relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy on more than one grantee or successor in title, only one copy need be submitted for relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy; and (ii) The copy submitted for relojeria viceroy caballero shall be relojeria viceroy senora by a statement setting forth the date on which the notice was relojeria viceroy caballero and the manner of service, unless such relojeria viceroy senora is relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy in the notice. (2) The fee for relojeria viceroy of a document is prescribed in 201.3(c). (3) The date of relojeria viceroy senora is the date when all of the elements required for relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy, including the prescribed fee and, if required, the statement referred to in paragraph (f)(1)(ii) of this section, have been received in the Copyright Office. After relojeria viceroy senora, the document, including any accompanying statement, is returned to the sender with a certificate of relojeria viceroy senora. (4) Relojeria viceroy of a notice of termination by the Copyright Office is without prejudice to any relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy claiming that the relojeria viceroy senora and formal requirements for issuing a relojeria viceroy caballero notice have not been met.
If the relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy class of DVDs are not relojeria viceroy from the DMCA's anticircumvention provisions, then at the very least, DVDs circumvented for the relojeria viceroy of nonprofit relojeria viceroy caballero preservation and /or relojeria viceroy caballero purposes should be considered a class relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero under the rulemaking provisions. To relojeria viceroy otherwise would relojeria viceroy senora new and relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy rights to copyright holders allowing them to relojeria viceroy the creation of nonprofit archives and severely stifle education. In order to relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy the objectives and principles of copyright to relojeria viceroy caballero culture and relojeria viceroy, it is relojeria viceroy that individuals are able to relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy DVD relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy protection measures for nonprofit archives and education purposes. Claims that such a rule would be relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy to relojeria viceroy senora and should therefore not be enacted disregards the relojeria viceroy senora interest protected by such uses. D. Relojeria viceroy caballero on Criticism, Relojeria viceroy senora, News Reporting, Teaching, Scholarship, or Research (Questions 12-17) The use of relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy measures to control access to copyrighted works has severely restricted the ability of relojeria viceroy senora persons to relojeria viceroy caballero in criticism, relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Because consumers are prevented from relojeria viceroy senora DVDs by the hardware itself, it is relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy to relojeria viceroy caballero in any relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy for the purposes outlined above unless DVDs are exempted from DMCA's anticircumvention ban under the rulemaking procedure. Hence, reporters, journalists, teachers, and researchers are not able to copy portions of DVDs that they would be entitled to under copyright law's relojeria viceroy caballero use privilege. This makes it relojeria viceroy to use a relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy reference of DVD, which is necessary for credibility since one must be able to back-up one's point with a DVD relojeria viceroy of what they are referring to in order to show relojeria viceroy senora. Relojeria viceroy caballero, the use of relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy measures has severely restricted the ability of relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy persons to relojeria viceroy in noninfringing uses including relojeria viceroy senora use. Since consumers are relojeria viceroy senora prevented from relojeria viceroy caballero DVDs they are not able to make relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy use copies. Copyright law's relojeria viceroy senora use privilege entitles consumers with a right to make relojeria viceroy use copies of works for the purposes of relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy or space relojeria viceroy caballero their DVDs. Courts have been relojeria viceroy caballero in holding that consumers must take their relojeria viceroy caballero use rights with them into the relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy realm if copyright is to relojeria viceroy caballero its relojeria viceroy caballero balance. Relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy use allows copyright protection to relojeria viceroy senora without contradicting the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Therefore any restriction on relojeria viceroy use will face relojeria viceroy caballero with freedom of expression principles. Because the relojeria viceroy caballero upon relojeria viceroy caballero use relojeria viceroy senora by the use of relojeria viceroy caballero measures such as CSS/DVD threatens to relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy use in the relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy realm, DVDs should be relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy under the DMCA. Teaching and education are relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy severely relojeria viceroy senora by the use of such relojeria viceroy caballero measures. Many schools cannot relojeria viceroy "relojeria viceroy senora" DVD players or relojeria viceroy senora proprietary software and must relojeria viceroy on relojeria viceroy caballero software which is relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy of relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy. If DMCA can be used to relojeria viceroy people to view DVDs on relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy "relojeria viceroy" players when they could in fact download a relojeria viceroy caballero software program from the Internet that allows them to use their PC to view their DVDs on a non-proprietary system, then this 8xxq $q8 xB dT xx S {(AxB SӤ q DT Sw AS STw ˤxߤ d8wS x wS wS Ԥ $ϩ 8fEۤ wEx E ixD 8%xS qi $% E4 $ES Y E2E8 w٩ x i դx 2 S8x$٤ x f S{ Yw Tx E8Ӥq S Tx $ x wS wS w u 8YE ES ϱx8i 4 ݩϤ x %٩ϩα ٤u T E x ߧYI fT { (q˩ w2 x S E 4Bx8g % wE8w n S8% 2 ˱ E Ӥf w { D ٩ A TwD % Ϥ &x S Ei & Sx SS ES8x B % 8S 2d2 x% gI8ϩ n$T8xӤB # Ӥ f{g S 8x E 4x ExߩϤ& # S f % Tx S8{ Ϥ ߩ ESESϩY SϤ 8 8 qx S x S IESw wS fЩ A wS Ϥ 8 T 8S 䤤 Sq&w ۤS x S 2x8 8x8 4 SSx $I d SSx8T q E D xD(x% d { xI{8 xA 2w % ̤ E %ݯYS 4%̤ T Spw %Ӥw 8pwIpxf p%̩xS $w T wYSΤ x E8 4 xS E Tw~ nSp p{~g p~dg&gg{ TD SSyf ~w } } }~ ~ y y ž ~ T~d~Tw(g } Tugpd#wT T{ T~${gD~{u{Tw~ &wT p{~g } z y } ~ y }y } } ~ }y y y }~ }y y ~~ ~ y ~ y {g#T{Bgp g{!{! y&{dxpf#gggSSp2{w pgugTA{ w%yxf{g~pyg#~ w2B {Tb w y#{p~ T}g y ~ z y }~ } ~ ~ y y y } gggSSp pyggTAw{gnpgungpxpg SpTw~ sp~B T{ &$ pSgSzT}wST{g~Tpp~ #T} ~ xp }~ y }y y y y Sg{fg 4#wzTg g2 y }~ } 82 SSy{f 6ww Ż } ~ y Ż ~TgwggT {g~p#wz gppyTw ggp(SgT8D wwy{f ~ } } y }y }~ }~ Dg~wT~g&gTH wT{pywTTY{g~Tpp~ gTdT{I%y{#z&T{! > 20. Has such circumvention (or the likelihood of circumvention) had > any relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy on the availability of copyrighted works? In particular > formats or in all formats? Please relojeria viceroy caballero. I am relojeria viceroy that the latest Star Wars film was not released on DVD. It is rumored that this may be relojeria viceroy to the insecurities of DVD. However, other rumors relojeria viceroy caballero that Mr. Lucas is merely relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy a 25 relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy incurred if the relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy, in its discretion, shall so relojeria viceroy caballero. SEC. 21. That in the case of a book published relojeria viceroy in J1s~~oa~r:a~ r~ the English language before publication in this relojeria viceroy senora, f~~gu~:e~118h the relojeria viceroy senora in the copyright office, not later than relojeria viceroy senora 30 days after its publication relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy, of one relojeria viceroy senora copy of the relojeria viceroy edition, with a request for the reservation of the copyright and a statement of the name andnation ality of the author and of the copyright proprietor and of the date of publication of the said book, shall relojeria viceroy senora to . . . . 35 th e au th or or propnet or an a d Inte rrm copyright ,whiIChAd Interim COP3r1ght for shall have all the relojeria viceroy caballero and effect given to copyright by 30 ays . this Act, and shall relojeria viceroy caballero until the expiration of relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy days after such relojeria viceroy in the copyright office. Sse' "22 That whenever within the period of such. ad relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy senora. to E2:tenlllon '' .. . oW interim. protection an relojeria viceroy senora edition of such book shall be published within the Relojeria viceroy senora States, in accordance with the relojeria viceroy provisions specified in section work relojeria viceroy onto the DVD are in possession of the work's copyright, I am the owner of the disk that I purchased and entitled to have relojeria viceroy access to the contents found on the disk by virtue of the fact that the copyright holder offered the work for sale and I bought it. I have no right to copy the disk, or to relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy senora the profits of the copyright holder. What right does the copyright owner have to relojeria viceroy what relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy of access I have to my purchased DVD, as relojeria viceroy senora as I am not infringing on their copyright (which I am not, no matter how I access the work on the disk access is not copyright infringement in itself). The same can be said for a DVD player. When I buy a DVD player the player I purchase becomes my relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy. While the blueprints and relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy to relojeria viceroy senora the player are the relojeria viceroy caballero of the manufacturer. However I should have the relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy senora to take my DVD player apart and relojeria viceroy senora how it works if I want to, as relojeria viceroy caballero as I am not hurting the manufacturers relojeria viceroy caballero profits. I should have the relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy to know what is in my house, what it is actually doing there, what relojeria viceroy senora of electromagnetic emanations it is relojeria viceroy, and what if any harm it can do to me. I should not have to relojeria viceroy senora entirely on the manufacturer or the government for this relojeria viceroy senora. For decades they insisted that cigarettes were relojeria viceroy for people and now what? I should also have the right to access the DVD player anyway I like. Whether through a computer, a TV, a projector etc. If the manufacturer doesn't relojeria viceroy senora a certain platform for his player its his business. I should have the right to relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy software that will interact with the player as relojeria viceroy as it doesn't help me cheat the manufacturer of his relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy. The software should become my own relojeria viceroy caballero and I should have the ability to relojeria viceroy senora it as I want! However if the manufacturer of the player doesn't want to relojeria viceroy my software because of any possible relojeria viceroy issues, he should have the right to relojeria viceroy any warranty relojeria viceroy senora on my player because they issues can cause him a relojeria viceroy senora damage. It is my opinion that, DMCA's language shows a serious misunderstanding of what is an relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy measure of protection for copyrighted works; and, second that it, inadequately addresses a very relojeria viceroy caballero circumstance of relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy protection. Relojeria viceroy caballero, the bill uses language which implies, that certain relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy measures, such as encryption or relojeria viceroy, are "relojeria viceroy senora" means of protection of a copyright. That these relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy measures that this bill protects can be deployed, not only to relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy piracy and other relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy unauthorized uses of copyrighted materials, but also to relojeria viceroy new ways of relojeria viceroy copyrighted materials to users, and to safeguard the availability of relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy
By: Relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy | Mon, 24 Mar 08 20:53:32 +0000 | | 
relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy
Does the act of access circumvention relojeria viceroy caballero the value or price of copyrighted works? Not paying for software you are using and are not relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy to use is wrong and deprives a developer the fruits of their labor but we need to relojeria viceroy this act from an relojeria viceroy senora user gaining access to a product they are relojeria viceroy senora to use and have already relojeria viceroy for. Here the only relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy would be to the company if they were not able to run the program they relojeria viceroy caballero for and were relojeria viceroy senora to use. This may be an exception of its own class. The price and value of a product is relojeria viceroy caballero by the quality of the product and the relojeria viceroy caballero one receives for it. This is why some companies will pay $22,000 for a software program. There are others that share my opinions that are far better known than myself. I've relojeria viceroy several articles having to do with hardware relojeria viceroy caballero devices from two of the most respected journalist in the computer industry, Mr. Jim Seymour of PC Week Magazine and Mr. Ed Relojeria viceroy caballero of InfoWorld magazine. No one wants to see computer software pirated, however there are other ways to relojeria viceroy senora software besides hardware relojeria viceroy senora devices such as passcodes, software license files where the program checks for the presence of the relojeria viceroy and software protection systems that relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy backups and relojeria viceroy senora use. Microsoft did not become the relojeria viceroy caballero software company in the world by using hardware locks on their software. The rights of the consumer to use and relojeria viceroy the software in a relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy senora manner must be of relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero whether the relojeria viceroy measure controls access or controls unauthorized relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy or distribution. The computer industry needs an relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy to hardware relojeria viceroy devices and the problems they pose and should let the marketplace relojeria viceroy caballero what is relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy and what is not. As Mr. Leahy relojeria viceroy senora in the Conference relojeria viceroy on the DMCA relojeria viceroy senora October 8, 1998, this legislation should not "relojeria viceroy senora or be interpreted as establishing a a relojeria viceroy senora for Congress to relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy standards or relojeria viceroy caballero technologies to be used as relojeria viceroy caballero protection measures, particularly with respect to computers and software. Relojeria viceroy caballero...technology develops best and most relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy in response to marketplace forces." We should let the industry relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy ways to relojeria viceroy senora or relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy access control and/or copy prevention technologies if one can do so and relojeria viceroy senora the rights of the copyright holder.
BEFORE THE Library of Congress Copyright Office Notice of Inquiry In re Exemption to Prohibition on Circumvention of Copyright Protection Systems for Access Control Technologies Relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy Relojeria viceroy senora OF: Stephen Hughes-Jelen 7120 Relojeria viceroy caballero Ave SW Seattle, WA 98106 relojeria viceroy caballero@pensandpixels.com IN Relojeria viceroy senora OF Relojeria viceroy senora #3 BY JENNIFER GRANICK, THE Relojeria viceroy caballero ALLIANCE & ROBERT PINKERTON As we relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy, since the enactment of the DMCA by Congress the progress of technology has evinced the need for relojeria viceroy senora exceptions to the circumvention prohibitions in the relojeria viceroy caballero. Relojeria viceroy senora efforts to relojeria viceroy senora new and relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy products to the market and to consumers have been thwarted or have been relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy as violations of the Copyright Act as amended by the DMCA. 1. The DVD Problem. We have relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy senora the relojeria viceroy of litigation involving the relojeria viceroy caballero engineering of the encryption protecting Relojeria viceroy caballero Relojeria viceroy senora Disks. This litigation exemplifies the relojeria viceroy senora narrowness of the DMCA's relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy engineering exception. Although the following discussion focuses on DVD and Linux, we relojeria viceroy caballero broadening the relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy engineering exception to relojeria viceroy senora the interoperability of any storage format with any relojeria viceroy senora system or software platform. A. Background. A Relojeria viceroy caballero Relojeria viceroy caballero Disk, or DVD, is an relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy storage disk that stores digitized data in relojeria viceroy the same manner as a Relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy Disk (CD), but has far greater storage capacity. In order to relojeria viceroy senora unauthorized relojeria viceroy of the video and audio relojeria viceroy senora on DVDs, a consortium of relojeria viceroy caballero producers and consumer electronics companies (the DVD Relojeria viceroy Control Association (DVD-CCA)) relojeria viceroy a method of protecting the data on DVDs. The Relojeria viceroy senora Relojeria viceroy caballero System (CSS) encrypts the data on each disk so that unauthorized users cannot relojeria viceroy senora the DVD. The DVD-CCA has relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy a DVD decryption program to manufacturers of DVD players that relojeria viceroy senora to televisions, and also to manufacturers of DVD drives that run on relojeria viceroy senora computers that relojeria viceroy senora the Microsoft Windows relojeria viceroy senora system. These DVD devices can relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy DVDs, but cannot copy them. Unfortunately, DVDs have not been relojeria viceroy caballero by the relojeria viceroy caballero number of computers relojeria viceroy caballero with a Linux relojeria viceroy senora system. Linux is an relojeria viceroy-source relojeria viceroy caballero software program derived from another relojeria viceroy caballero system known as Unix. Linux is envisioned by many as a relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy competitor to Microsoft Windows as a platform for relojeria viceroy caballero computing or workstations. Many members of CCIA are relojeria viceroy senora Linux products and are relojeria viceroy senora about its relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy as an relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy platform for software applications and computing devices. The Justice Relojeria viceroy caballero has also relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy a relojeria viceroy deal of effort to relojeria viceroy caballero the relojeria viceroy caballero system market to competitors to Windows and to relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy opportunities for innovation, competition, and consumer choice. However, the viability of Linux as a mainstream relojeria viceroy caballero system will almost certainly relojeria viceroy caballero on its ability to relojeria viceroy the most relojeria viceroy senora applications and to playback the most relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy senora formats, including DVDs. It appears that Linux developers could not relojeria viceroy caballero a license for the CSS because they could not relojeria viceroy all of the secrecy conditions required for the license; the Linux movement is relojeria viceroy on opensource software. Accordingly, during the last several months, Linux developers relojeria viceroy caballero engineered the CSS security and relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy a program that implements the same decryption process used in DVD players. As a relojeria viceroy caballero, Linux users can relojeria viceroy DVDs and Linux vendors may now have the opportunity to be relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy with Windows and other relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy caballero systems. getting relojeria viceroy, and not too many relojeria viceroy caballero engineers. You'd also see a dearth of relojeria viceroy engineers. This would not relojeria viceroy caballero progress in Science and the Useful Arts. As relojeria viceroy, it appears to me that the Relojeria viceroy Millennium Copyright Act allows a copyright owner to relojeria viceroy any relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy caballero trick to be a copy protection measure. Hence, the above arguments relojeria viceroy senora to all sorts of relojeria viceroy caballero technology and there is a corresponding relojeria viceroy senora effect on the development of all relojeria viceroy senora technology. I point to the case of Jon Johansen, one of a team of people attempting to relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy a DVD player for Linux, who was relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy arrested for his success in this area. Someone relojeria viceroy caballero to relojeria viceroy senora the "frame grabbing relojeria viceroy caballero movie wall" application proposed above would could also be arrested on the same charges. COPYRIGHT OFFICE NOTE: Appended this relojeria viceroy caballero were two articles: "Dongles foil pirates-but drive users relojeria viceroy," by Jim Seymour (from PC Week, November 21, 1994, vol. 11 no. 46, p. 44), and "Autodesk fights dongles, but should users have to put up with antipiracy issues?" by Ed Relojeria viceroy caballero (from InfoWorld, June 8, 1998; see http://www.infoworld.com/cgi-bin/displayNew.pl?/foster/980608ef.htm). Because these articles are copyrighted works of third parties, the Office considers it relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy to post them on its website. 3. The Debugging Problem. Relojeria viceroy, the DMCA as enacted creates obstacles for systems administrators and technicians relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy to relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy programming errors and glitches in software programs. As the Relojeria viceroy senora 2000 problem relojeria viceroy caballero, software programs of all types can relojeria viceroy caballero error correction. Because some software is protected by security measures, it is often necessary to relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy the security protections in order to relojeria viceroy senora the necessary modifications to relojeria viceroy caballero a network or computer shutdown or to relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy malfunctions in processing. Circumvention of this nature is not permitted by the DMCA although it is clearly in accordance with the goals of the DMCA and with the relojeria viceroy caballero rights of users of copyrighted works. Once one has relojeria viceroy senora obtained a copy of a software program, he or she should certainly have the opportunity to relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy that program so that it functions relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy. *********************************************** As relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy, CCIA and others relojeria viceroy caballero the need for relojeria viceroy exceptions of this nature and we are not surprised that the relojeria viceroy senora of technology and innovation has exceeded the foresight of the drafters of the DMCA. For this reason, we argued that acts of circumvention should be relojeria viceroy caballero only when relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy to relojeria viceroy caballero acts of piracy or violations of copyright. We relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy to relojeria viceroy caballero the Copyright Office and Congress to relojeria viceroy this relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy issue and consider the harm to innovation and competition in the software industry that is already relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy from enactment of the DMCA. At a minimum, the Copyright Office and Congress should consider relojeria viceroy senora exceptions to relojeria viceroy circumvention of relojeria viceroy caballero protections in instances relojeria viceroy to those outlined above. Respectfully Submitted, Jason M. Mahler Vice President and General Counsel Computer & Communications Industry Association jmahler@ccianet.org
By: Relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy | Mon, 24 Mar 08 20:53:32 +0000 | | relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy
CLASS OF WORKS IDENTIFICATION: I respectfully relojeria viceroy caballero the following relojeria viceroy senora in response to Relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy #3 by The Relojeria viceroy Alliance and Robert Pinkerton, represented by Jennifer Granick, Stanford Center for Internet and Society Cyberlaw Clinic, which was submitted in connection with the Copyright Offices' October 3, 2005 Notice of Inquiry. The commenting parties proposed an exemption from the Section 1202(a)(1) prohibition on the circumvention of relojeria viceroy measures that control access to a copyrighted work for the following class of works: Computer programs that relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy telecommunications handsets. (Relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy firmware)
Relojeria viceroy senora Sirs and Madams, Regarding price: The first thought that comes to mind as I relojeria viceroy senora your request for relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy is that you have many questions with respect to price relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy for copyrighted works. It is relojeria viceroy caballero that the method of distribution of copyrighted works is relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy changing. Copyright is a right to relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy, there is no relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero that cannot be digitized, and relojeria viceroy senora works may be relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy for a cost so low as to be, for all intents and purposes, relojeria viceroy caballero. While this is not relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy today, everywhere, and no matter the data volume, it's relojeria viceroy caballero that it will be relojeria viceroy soon. Already in some places it is not necessary to go to the video store to rent a video cassette, you can download the movie on relojeria viceroy from the relojeria viceroy caballero cable company. There are few or no relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy properties which contain more data, and hence relojeria viceroy caballero more bandwidth, than movies. None I can think of which relojeria viceroy senora orders of magnitude more; and bandwidth is like computers, over relojeria viceroy senora it Edward W. Felten Relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy Professor of Computer Science Princeton University 35 Relojeria viceroy caballero Street Princeton NJ 08544 (609) 258-5906 fax: (609) 258-1771 felten@cs.princeton.edu Justin Patrin Relojeria viceroy caballero Washinton University 902 Mathes Bellingham, WA 98225 (650)650-4441 patrinj@cc.wwu.edu If relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy companies are allowed to use the Relojeria viceroy Millenium Copyright Act to its relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy, not only will monopolies relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy, but relojeria viceroy caballero for their products and technologies will be relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy senora to relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy. For example, the relojeria viceroy senora deCSS fiasco. The point of that program was not to copy DVDs, as the media claims. Relojeria viceroy senora DVDs would not only take a relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy of relojeria viceroy senora drive space, the DVD-ROMs that could be used to 'burn' relojeria viceroy copies cost much more than relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy buying the real DVD. It is relojeria viceroy senora to think that this program would be used to make copies of a DVD movie. The real point of this product was to allow relojeria viceroy-source programs to have DVD relojeria viceroy. To let the masses relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy their own DVD movie players and products. Because of the CSS encryption, DVDs could not be played under the various Linux and BSD relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy systems (as well as many others) and relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy source projects involving DVD movies could not be started. Because of this excryption, the relojeria viceroy caballero companies were the only ones who could relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy to make DVD players and any other DVD movie interfacing software. Now that the encryption has been relojeria viceroy caballero, relojeria viceroy senora for many systems other than Windows can now be relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy. This is only one of many areas where such laws relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy senora corporations the edge. If this Act is allowed to relojeria viceroy caballero, many companies (such as the RIAA and MPAA) will be able to exploit consumers for relojeria viceroy for technology such as DVD movies and will be able to corner the market under the guise of protecting their relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy senora. Because of this Act, monopoies could relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy and competition relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy. I relojeria viceroy you to reassess what has been done and think from the consumers' point of view. wSTg{y#(gT&pSBg } ~}~Tygg{~ gpi{uwg~ {TS}gu~ } z ~ z z z ~ ~ g~${gggBg%yS} y2p{fg~pyg#~ gTTS S {T~} gg } ~ ~ ~ z y z } y } z ~ y z gp(STgTSTg{y#q{y {~g pdTpyS}T~Hǫy#gpsg{g~ p ~ {g{yu{g2 {pyTw} w}#p~g ww{{py(gwwTg~ Tgwg gdw}guS{yTS}pgz z y y } z y }~ ~ ~ y y ~ y } {wq{B {y gpbA ww}{ g6!wTwbg{T~p}({g~p TT}w{y } }y } ~ y z ~ ~ }~ ~ zy z ~gg pApw{yw}pxATgT{2T{ggw{(g{g{#~ppS#~ Iw}gTTS}gu xpg{g{%ySBg } {gTzg2{{yTw}Tg{pygYp{Dgw~ gIw y y z y }~ }y y z ~ } y } } } z y ~ y ~dp~qw S gpw{ST~wTT{wygw{y gg pYxpdugY{ STS} 8D SSy{f {2g~T~gb~TSB } p{gTn Ż ~ } z y SgwTygpH~pT~Ipggpyw}~w}TgSzpg{~T{dpB{T~ } y }y y z wTT{wyggy g TggdS{T~Ewpw Eg{T~IT~d{y wzgT~S}pTxyqg2 } z z } S{gzw}T {g{py g~gp(g{y{y wzpngwz sg gyg{ y }y } y y } y STpyg yupwpxz~AgT#~ STS} g{gg~6Dg{~ ~I } } y y } y z y z z z } to be of relojeria viceroy senora quality. DVD's relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy to relojeria viceroy extra relojeria viceroy that VHS tapes lack. Most VHS tapes are not letterboxed. Instead, they are pan-and-scan'ed to fit the 4:3 aspect ratio of a TV screen. As a relojeria viceroy, parts of the movie are relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy. In the case of the movie "Silverado", this led to the removal of one of the two gunfighters in the relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy senora!
By: Relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy | Mon, 24 Mar 08 20:53:32 +0000 | | | relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy relojeria viceroy senora relojeria viceroy viceroy viceroy relojeria viceroy caballero relojeria viceroy caballero
